First Building - First Methodist/Methodist Episcopal     N. Pinkney & E. Mifflin     Built 1849-1853
Dedicated September 11, 1853

Second Building - First Methodist     203 Wisconsin Ave.     Built 1872-1887     Demolished 1975     Gothic Revival
1872 the land on the corner of Wisconsin Avenue and East Dayton Street was purchased. Cornerstone for the church building laid September 29,1873

Third Building -
A merger between the Evangelical United Brethren Church and The Methodist Church occurred in 1968. A church of each denomination was located on the same city block at that time so they consolidated into one building. On February 2, 1975, the new sanctuary was consecrated.